Punches Recipes Hot-buttered Rum Recipe Ingredients 1 tsp sugar1/2 tsp butter1 jigger rum4 cloves Place the sugar, butter, rum (light or dark) and cloves into a mug. Fill with boiling water, and stir. Spread the love Related posts: Hot Buttered Rum Recipe Hot Brick Toddy Recipe Hot Butter Scotch Toddy Recipe Tom And Jerry Recipe Medd Recipe Cranberry Tea Hot Punch Recipe